cmake_parse_arguments: add KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES

Add KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES output variable to cmake_parse_arguments() to
allow to detect keywords that received no values.

Fixes: #18706

Help/command/cmake_parse_arguments.rst

@@ -59,6 +59,11 @@ All remaining arguments are collected in a variable
 where recognized. This can be checked afterwards to see
 whether your macro was called with unrecognized parameters.
 
+``<one_value_keywords>`` and ``<multi_value_keywords>`` that where given no
+values at all are collected in a variable ``<prefix>_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES``
+that will be undefined if all keywords received values. This can be checked
+to see if there where keywords without any values given.
+
 As an example here a ``my_install()`` macro, which takes similar arguments
 as the real :command:`install` command:
 
@@ -77,7 +82,7 @@ Assume ``my_install()`` has been called like this:
 
 .. code-block:: cmake
 
-   my_install(TARGETS foo bar DESTINATION bin OPTIONAL blub)
+   my_install(TARGETS foo bar DESTINATION bin OPTIONAL blub CONFIGURATIONS)
 
 After the ``cmake_parse_arguments`` call the macro will have set or undefined
 the following variables::
@@ -89,6 +94,8 @@ the following variables::
    MY_INSTALL_TARGETS = "foo;bar"
    MY_INSTALL_CONFIGURATIONS <UNDEFINED> # was not used
    MY_INSTALL_UNPARSED_ARGUMENTS = "blub" # nothing expected after "OPTIONAL"
+   MY_INSTALL_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES = "CONFIGURATIONS"
+            # No value for "CONFIGURATIONS" given
 
 You can then continue and process these variables.
 
@@ -97,5 +104,6 @@ one_value_keyword another recognized keyword follows, this is
 interpreted as the beginning of the new option.  E.g.
 ``my_install(TARGETS foo DESTINATION OPTIONAL)`` would result in
 ``MY_INSTALL_DESTINATION`` set to ``"OPTIONAL"``, but as ``OPTIONAL``
-is a keyword itself ``MY_INSTALL_DESTINATION`` will be empty and
-``MY_INSTALL_OPTIONAL`` will therefore be set to ``TRUE``.
+is a keyword itself ``MY_INSTALL_DESTINATION`` will be empty (but added
+to ``MY_INSTALL_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES``) and ``MY_INSTALL_OPTIONAL`` will
+therefore be set to ``TRUE``.

Help/release/dev/cmake_parse_arguments-keywords_missing_values.rst

@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
+cmake_parse_arguments-keywords_missing_values
+---------------------------------------------
+
+* The :command:`cmake_parse_arguments` command gained an additional
+  ``<prefix>_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES`` output variable to report
+  keyword arguments that were given by the caller with no values.

Source/cmParseArgumentsCommand.cxx

@@ -14,7 +14,7 @@
 
 class cmExecutionStatus;
 
-static std::string escape_arg(const std::string& arg)
+static std::string EscapeArg(const std::string& arg)
 {
   // replace ";" with "\;" so output argument lists will split correctly
   std::string escapedArg;
@@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ static std::string escape_arg(const std::string& arg)
 }
 
 namespace {
-enum InsideValues
+enum insideValues
 {
   NONE,
   SINGLE,
@@ -38,6 +38,22 @@ enum InsideValues
 typedef std::map<std::string, bool> options_map;
 typedef std::map<std::string, std::string> single_map;
 typedef std::map<std::string, std::vector<std::string>> multi_map;
+typedef std::set<std::string> options_set;
+}
+
+// function to be called every time, a new key word was parsed or all
+// parameters where parsed.
+static void DetectKeywordsMissingValues(insideValues currentState,
+                                        const std::string& currentArgName,
+                                        int& argumentsFound,
+                                        options_set& keywordsMissingValues)
+{
+  if (currentState == SINGLE ||
+      (currentState == MULTI && argumentsFound == 0)) {
+    keywordsMissingValues.insert(currentArgName);
+  }
+
+  argumentsFound = 0;
 }
 
 static void PassParsedArguments(const std::string& prefix,
@@ -45,7 +61,8 @@ static void PassParsedArguments(const std::string& prefix,
                                 const options_map& options,
                                 const single_map& singleValArgs,
                                 const multi_map& multiValArgs,
-                                const std::vector<std::string>& unparsed)
+                                const std::vector<std::string>& unparsed,
+                                const options_set& keywordsMissingValues)
 {
   for (auto const& iter : options) {
     makefile.AddDefinition(prefix + iter.first,
@@ -75,6 +92,14 @@ static void PassParsedArguments(const std::string& prefix,
   } else {
     makefile.RemoveDefinition(prefix + "UNPARSED_ARGUMENTS");
   }
+
+  if (!keywordsMissingValues.empty()) {
+    makefile.AddDefinition(
+      prefix + "KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES",
+      cmJoin(cmMakeRange(keywordsMissingValues), ";").c_str());
+  } else {
+    makefile.RemoveDefinition(prefix + "KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES");
+  }
 }
 
 bool cmParseArgumentsCommand::InitialPass(std::vector<std::string> const& args,
@@ -161,7 +186,7 @@ bool cmParseArgumentsCommand::InitialPass(std::vector<std::string> const& args,
     multiValArgs[iter]; // default initialize
   }
 
-  InsideValues insideValues = NONE;
+  insideValues insideValues = NONE;
   std::string currentArgName;
 
   list.clear();
@@ -197,10 +222,15 @@ bool cmParseArgumentsCommand::InitialPass(std::vector<std::string> const& args,
     }
   }
 
+  options_set keywordsMissingValues;
+  int multiArgumentsFound = 0;
+
   // iterate over the arguments list and fill in the values where applicable
   for (std::string const& arg : list) {
     const options_map::iterator optIter = options.find(arg);
     if (optIter != options.end()) {
+      DetectKeywordsMissingValues(insideValues, currentArgName,
+                                  multiArgumentsFound, keywordsMissingValues);
       insideValues = NONE;
       optIter->second = true;
       continue;
@@ -208,6 +238,8 @@ bool cmParseArgumentsCommand::InitialPass(std::vector<std::string> const& args,
 
     const single_map::iterator singleIter = singleValArgs.find(arg);
     if (singleIter != singleValArgs.end()) {
+      DetectKeywordsMissingValues(insideValues, currentArgName,
+                                  multiArgumentsFound, keywordsMissingValues);
       insideValues = SINGLE;
       currentArgName = arg;
       continue;
@@ -215,6 +247,8 @@ bool cmParseArgumentsCommand::InitialPass(std::vector<std::string> const& args,
 
     const multi_map::iterator multiIter = multiValArgs.find(arg);
     if (multiIter != multiValArgs.end()) {
+      DetectKeywordsMissingValues(insideValues, currentArgName,
+                                  multiArgumentsFound, keywordsMissingValues);
       insideValues = MULTI;
       currentArgName = arg;
       continue;
@@ -226,15 +260,18 @@ bool cmParseArgumentsCommand::InitialPass(std::vector<std::string> const& args,
         insideValues = NONE;
         break;
       case MULTI:
+        ++multiArgumentsFound;
         if (parseFromArgV) {
-          multiValArgs[currentArgName].push_back(escape_arg(arg));
+          multiValArgs[currentArgName].push_back(EscapeArg(arg));
         } else {
           multiValArgs[currentArgName].push_back(arg);
         }
         break;
       default:
+        multiArgumentsFound = 0;
+
         if (parseFromArgV) {
-          unparsed.push_back(escape_arg(arg));
+          unparsed.push_back(EscapeArg(arg));
         } else {
           unparsed.push_back(arg);
         }
@@ -242,8 +279,11 @@ bool cmParseArgumentsCommand::InitialPass(std::vector<std::string> const& args,
     }
   }
 
+  DetectKeywordsMissingValues(insideValues, currentArgName,
+                              multiArgumentsFound, keywordsMissingValues);
+
   PassParsedArguments(prefix, *this->Makefile, options, singleValArgs,
-                      multiValArgs, unparsed);
+                      multiValArgs, unparsed, keywordsMissingValues);
 
   return true;
 }

Tests/RunCMake/cmake_parse_arguments/KeyWordsMissingValues.cmake

@@ -0,0 +1,133 @@
+include(${CMAKE_CURRENT_LIST_DIR}/test_utils.cmake)
+
+# No keywords that miss any values, _KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES should not be defined
+cmake_parse_arguments(PREF "" "P1" "P2" P1 p1 P2 p2_a p2_b)
+
+TEST(PREF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "UNDEFINED")
+
+# Keyword should even be deleted from the actual scope
+set(PREF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "What ever")
+cmake_parse_arguments(PREF "" "" "")
+
+TEST(PREF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "UNDEFINED")
+
+# Given missing keywords as only option
+cmake_parse_arguments(PREF "" "P1" "P2" P1)
+
+TEST(PREF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "P1")
+TEST(PREF_P1 "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(PREF_UNPARSED_ARGUMENTS "UNDEFINED")
+
+# Mixed with unparsed arguments
+cmake_parse_arguments(UPREF "" "P1" "P2" A B P2 C P1)
+TEST(UPREF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "P1")
+TEST(UPREF_UNPARSED_ARGUMENTS A B)
+
+# one_value_keyword followed by option
+cmake_parse_arguments(REF "OP" "P1" "" P1 OP)
+TEST(REF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "P1")
+TEST(REF_UNPARSED_ARGUMENTS "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_OP "TRUE")
+
+# Counter Test
+cmake_parse_arguments(REF "OP" "P1" "" P1 p1 OP)
+TEST(REF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_P1 "p1")
+TEST(REF_UNPARSED_ARGUMENTS "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_OP "TRUE")
+
+# one_value_keyword followed by a one_value_keyword
+cmake_parse_arguments(REF "" "P1;P2" "" P1 P2 p2)
+TEST(REF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "P1")
+TEST(REF_P1 "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_UNPARSED_ARGUMENTS "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_P2 "p2")
+
+# Counter Test
+cmake_parse_arguments(REF "" "P1;P2" "" P1 p1 P2 p2)
+TEST(REF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_P1 "p1")
+TEST(REF_UNPARSED_ARGUMENTS "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_P2 "p2")
+
+# one_value_keyword followed by a multi_value_keywords
+cmake_parse_arguments(REF "" "P1" "P2" P1 P2 p1 p2)
+TEST(REF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "P1")
+TEST(REF_P1 "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_UNPARSED_ARGUMENTS "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_P2 p1 p2)
+
+# Counter Examples
+cmake_parse_arguments(REF "" "P1" "P2" P1 p1 P2 p1 p2)
+TEST(REF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_P1 "p1")
+TEST(REF_UNPARSED_ARGUMENTS "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_P2 p1 p2)
+
+# multi_value_keywords as only option
+cmake_parse_arguments(REF "" "P1" "P2" P2)
+TEST(REF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "P2")
+TEST(REF_P1 "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_UNPARSED_ARGUMENTS "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_P2 "UNDEFINED")
+
+# multi_value_keywords followed by option
+cmake_parse_arguments(REF "O1" "" "P1" P1 O1)
+TEST(REF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "P1")
+TEST(REF_P1 "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_UNPARSED_ARGUMENTS "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_O1 "TRUE")
+
+# counter test
+cmake_parse_arguments(REF "O1" "" "P1" P1 p1 p2 O1)
+TEST(REF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_P1 "p1;p2")
+TEST(REF_UNPARSED_ARGUMENTS "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_O1 "TRUE")
+
+# multi_value_keywords followed by one_value_keyword
+cmake_parse_arguments(REF "" "P1" "P2" P2 P1 p1)
+TEST(REF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "P2")
+TEST(REF_P1 "p1")
+TEST(REF_UNPARSED_ARGUMENTS "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_P2 "UNDEFINED")
+
+# counter test
+cmake_parse_arguments(REF "" "P1" "P2" P2 p2 P1 p1)
+TEST(REF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_P1 "p1")
+TEST(REF_UNPARSED_ARGUMENTS "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_P2 "p2")
+
+# one_value_keyword as last argument
+cmake_parse_arguments(REF "" "P1" "P2" A P2 p2 P1)
+TEST(REF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "P1")
+TEST(REF_P1 "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_UNPARSED_ARGUMENTS "A")
+TEST(REF_P2 "p2")
+
+# multi_value_keywords as last argument
+cmake_parse_arguments(REF "" "P1" "P2" P1 p1 P2)
+TEST(REF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "P2")
+TEST(REF_P1 "p1")
+TEST(REF_P2 "UNDEFINED")
+
+# Multiple one_value_keyword and multi_value_keywords at different places
+cmake_parse_arguments(REF "O1;O2" "P1" "P2" P1 O1 P2 O2)
+TEST(REF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES P1 P2)
+TEST(REF_P1 "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_P2 "UNDEFINED")
+
+# Duplicated missing keywords
+cmake_parse_arguments(REF "O1;O2" "P1" "P2" P1 O1 P2 O2 P1 P2)
+TEST(REF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES P1 P2)
+TEST(REF_P1 "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_P2 "UNDEFINED")
+
+# make sure keywords that are never used, don't get added to KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES
+cmake_parse_arguments(REF "O1;O2" "P1" "P2")
+TEST(REF_KEYWORDS_MISSING_VALUES "UNDEFINED")
+TEST(REF_O1 FALSE)
+TEST(REF_O2 FALSE)
+TEST(REF_P1 UNDEFINED)
+TEST(REF_P2 UNDEFINED)

Tests/RunCMake/cmake_parse_arguments/RunCMakeTest.cmake

@@ -11,3 +11,4 @@ run_cmake(BadArgvN2)
 run_cmake(BadArgvN3)
 run_cmake(BadArgvN4)
 run_cmake(CornerCasesArgvN)
+run_cmake(KeyWordsMissingValues)